Published Wednesday, November 18, 2026. Susan Smith's second parole hearing is scheduled for Thursday, November 19, before the South Carolina Board of Paroles and Pardons in Columbia. This story will be updated when the board decides.

Susan Smith goes before a South Carolina parole board tomorrow — 32 years after she drowned her two little boys in a lake and told the whole country a stranger had taken them. Her ex-husband David Smith will be in the room to argue against her release, and in interviews this week he put it as plainly as he could: if it were up to him, she would stay in prison until she dies.

Smith, 55, has spent more than three decades behind bars for murdering her sons, 3-year-old Michael and 14-month-old Alexander, in October 1994. She is serving a life sentence at the Leath Correctional Institution in Greenwood, South Carolina. Thursday's hearing is her second bid for freedom. Her first, in November 2024, was unanimously denied — and this time, the people who knew the case best are lining up to oppose her again.

The Father Who Can Barely Remember His Sons

David Smith, 56, gave a series of interviews this week ahead of the hearing, and the most painful part of them had nothing to do with his ex-wife. Speaking to People in an exclusive interview published November 18, he said that after 32 years he can barely remember his own sons at all. “I remember maybe quotes that they used to say, a few of those,” he said. “Words they used to spell or they would pronounce so childish in their own childish ways. But memories, there aren't any.”

What he does remember are fragments of sound. Michael, a fan of the movie 101 Dalmatians, pronounced it “101 Domashafens.” He never said “Alex is my brother” — he said, “He's my brudder.” David keeps a few photographs of the boys around the house he shares with his wife, Tiffany, but he has deliberately avoided turning his home into a memorial. “I've never wanted to create a shrine because I knew that wasn't healthy for me,” he told People. “Their memories are always alive in my heart.” When people ask how old his sons would be today, he says he cannot process the question. To him, they will always be 3 years and 14 months old.

His position on his ex-wife's release has not moved. In a CNN report published November 15, David said: “If I have a choice, I'd want her to stay in prison until she dies.” He told the network he does not believe Susan has ever shown genuine remorse — “She has never even said ‘I'm sorry,'” he said — and he does not believe she has been rehabilitated. He also worries, openly, that this hearing could go differently from the last one. “So many people tell me that it won't happen, and I wish that would make it so it wouldn't happen, but it's not a guarantee,” he told People. “That's totally up to the parole board. And I'm just worried that this time could be the one where she gets parole.” Freeing her, he said, would be “an injustice” to his sons.

He will not be the only voice against release. The lead prosecutor in the case, Tommy Pope, plans to attend the hearing to oppose it, and Union County Sheriff's Office Chief Deputy Scott Coffer intends to appear before the board as well. Even Tracey Thompson — a former inmate who says she was romantically involved with Smith in prison — has said Smith should stay behind bars, telling Radar Online that “she did something horrible” and “belongs in jail for the rest of her life.” And strangers still visit the boys' gravesite, leaving toys and small tokens. “That is such a sweet, kind gesture,” David told People. “It makes my heart smile when I see that, to know that those people that never even knew Michael and Alex still care enough to come.”

THE STORY SO FAR

October 25, 1994 — Susan Smith, then 23, straps Michael, 3, and Alexander, 14 months, into their car seats in her maroon Mazda Protegé and lets the car roll down a boat ramp into John D. Long Lake in Union, South Carolina. She tells police a Black man carjacked her at a stoplight with her children still inside. October 25 to November 3, 1994 — a nine-day search grips the country; Smith makes tearful televised pleas for her boys' return, with David standing beside her. November 3, 1994 — Smith confesses and leads investigators to the lake, where the car is found upside down with the boys still strapped into their seats; Michael's small hand was pressed against a window. July 1995 — a jury convicts her of two counts of murder; prosecutors had sought the death penalty, and her lawyers had argued severe depression drove a murder-suicide attempt. She is sentenced to life in prison with the possibility of parole after 30 years. November 20, 2024 — her first parole hearing: the board unanimously denies release after David tells the board that 30 years amounts to 15 years per child. November 19, 2026 — her second hearing, in Columbia.

Why She Can Ask For Parole At All

The reason Smith is even eligible comes down to the law as it stood when she was sentenced. Under South Carolina law at the time, a life sentence carried the possibility of parole after 30 years — so she became eligible in November 2024, once three decades had passed. The law was changed shortly after her conviction: people sentenced to life for a murder committed after January 1, 1996, are not eligible for parole at all. Smith's case falls on the old side of that line, which is why she can keep asking — and why, if the board denies her again, she can ask again in two years.

WHAT HAPPENS NEXT

The board hears Smith's case on Thursday, November 19, in Columbia. David Smith, prosecutor Tommy Pope and Sheriff's Chief Deputy Scott Coffer are all expected to speak against her release, and Smith herself will have the chance to make her case. If the board denies her again, her next review comes in two years, in 2028. If it grants parole, she would be released under supervision, with conditions set by the board. Either way, the decision rests entirely with the parole board — and until it rules, nothing about her freedom has been decided.